My Top 6 Reasons Diets Fail

Article by Nicole Malone

Photography by Nicole Malone

The term "diet" actually comes from an ancient Greek word meaning "a mode of living." More recently, it has taken on a new meaning that is "to select or limit the food one eats to either lose, gain, or maintain weight." For the purposes of this discussion, "diet" is being referred to as a weight loss term. There are so many reasons diets fail. Of course, many of the reasons are person and situation dependent, however, they still hold true for the vast majority of individuals. So, here are my top 6 reasons diets fail:

1. Unrealistic Goals

You cannot possibly expect to change all of your eating habits overnight and expect lasting change and results. Too often, people want a magic pill to just make the weight go away overnight or that quick fix. This is what mass marketing takes advantage of with diet teas, diet pills, and all the popular fad and yo-yo diets out there. It is sad but true that lasting change takes time, and if you truly want change, then you need to be patient and trust in the process. It is unrealistic to think that you can lose, for example, 20 pounds in one month, but that is what a lot of people want and expect: fast results in as little effort and time as possible. Set more realistic, achievable, and sustainable goals at the start, and that will almost certainly set you up for success. Start by making small changes, such as limiting your soda consumption or making an effort to exercise consistently. And notice how I said limit your soda and not eliminate soda altogether. And that brings me to reason No. 2 of why diets fail.

2. Restrictiveness

Most mainstream diets deprive us or even completely eliminate certain nutrients unnecessarily. This deprivation is simply not realistic, sustainable, or even healthy for that matter. Restricting nutrients from your diet can lead to not-so-nice side effects such as headaches, fatigue, grogginess, brain fog, dizziness, irritability, and the list goes on. This is likely due to not eating enough calories or even not getting enough carbohydrates. I say carbs specifically because that is the go-to macronutrient most eliminate or limit when losing weight because the belief is carbs make you fat and are bad. Well, that is simply not true, and you can check previous posts on this very topic, but I will let that die here for this particular discussion. The bottom line is this: Being hungry does not necessarily equate to losing weight. The goal here should be to find a plan that works for you, your body, and your goals and of course a plan that you can stick to for the long haul. You should choose foods that have a higher thermic effect and will leave you feeling fuller longer such as lean proteins, good sources of fat and of course fiber. Stop skipping meals!

3. Too Much Counting

Yes, calories are important in that when you are trying to lose weight the goal is to get yourself in a caloric deficit. But being overly strict and obsessive about counting and tracking can lead to anxiety, stress, and ultimately failure because it just becomes too hard to keep up with and manage. Counting calories accurately is extremely difficult, even for seasoned professionals, and if you are eating out, it gets even harder with all the “hidden calories” there may be. While it is important to decrease the number of calories you are consuming when trying to lose weight, it is even more important to consume the nutrients your body needs to function optimally. Of course, you should be aware of the calories you are consuming, but don’t let that be the only and final decision maker. The quality of food matters just as much, if not even more if your ultimate end goal is to lose weight and achieve optimal health.  

4. Inadequate Sleep

Sleep is often overlooked when it comes to health and wellness. Sleep actually plays a vital role in your physical and even mental health. Getting enough good quality sleep, recommended between 7-9 hours a night, helps you maintain a healthy balance of hormones such as the hunger hormone, ghrelin, and the fullness hormone, leptin. I am sure you all have experienced increased cravings and lack of will power when you get inadequate sleep. That is because when you don’t get enough sleep, your ghrelin levels increase while your leptin levels decrease; this results in you feeling hungrier than you normally would be if you were well-rested. Further, sleep deficiency is linked to increased risk of heart disease, high blood pressure, stroke, obesity (for the reasons just described), as well as depression. Ensure sleep is a priority and aim for between 7-9 hours a night or at least most nights and you will be golden!

5. Consistency

Consistency when starting anything new is key. Building new habits and improving your overall health is not going to be easy and is going to take a lot of time and effort. When starting something new, start slow then gradually advance. The tendency is to essentially come out of the gate too hot and quickly realize that the pace you set for yourself is simply too much and you can’t keep up. Find a pace that works for you and your lifestyle at the very start when it comes to diet and exercise. Once you get in a rhythm, it is important to hold yourself accountable. It’s easy to skip workouts or eat unhealthy foods, so it is important to hold yourself accountable and keep yourself in check, especially in the beginning. A good tip is to maybe have an accountability buddy in the beginning because no one wants to disappoint someone else. Lastly, set rules for yourself and stick to them! For instance, one of my rules is to never go more than two days in a row without working out. So, set similar rules for yourself for both exercise and your nutrition plan—something you can stick with and is sustainable.  

6. All-or-Nothing Mentality

Stop starting over! With this all-or-nothing mentality, it is very easy to get discouraged or even give up or fall off the wagon the second you feel you messed up. It is important to realize that no one is perfect and no one is asking you to try to be. Take each situation you consider a setback as a lesson and something to learn from. Then brush yourself off and get back at it! “The task ahead of you is never greater than the strength within you.” Cheesy? I know, but applicable nonetheless.

There you have it. My top 6 reasons why diets fail. There are probably more that can be added to the list, but I think these are the most common. To be successful on a diet, slowly make it a part of your daily lifestyle and habits. Lasting results don’t come from quick fixes or crash diets. Lasting change comes down to incorporating habits and small adjustments that become second nature and are sustainable for the long haul. Start slow and gradually add as you feel you are able. I will leave you with this: daily action ignites the momentum that creates lasting change.  

Related Businesses

The Stretch Mobility Coach


The Stretch Mobility Coach

West Chester, OH

We are a team of Physical Therapists, Physical Therapist Assistants, Massage Therapists and Wellness Coaches that help you...

Idaho Nutrition Associates


Idaho Nutrition Associates

Boise, ID

We are a team of several Registered Dietitians helping people thrive in their life by: Preventing and managing diseases...

Lifequest Physical Medicine And Rehab


Lifequest Physical Medicine And Rehab

Gilbert, AZ

Our clinics provide advanced diagnostics, preventive care, and physical rehabilitation in Gilbert, AZ + Chandler, AZ. With...

See More

Related Articles

See More