There’s nothing like stumbling upon a new favorite restaurant, where the food is so good you’ll dream about it later. Whether it’s a cozy spot for a weekday dinner, a lively place to unwind with friends or a hidden gem you’ve been dying to show off, Northwest Columbus has got you covered. With flavors that range from hearty comfort food to vibrant global cuisine, our area is packed with eateries that know how to dish up something special. So, if you’re ready to treat your taste buds to something extraordinary, we’ve rounded up some of the best spots to satisfy your cravings.
The Whitney House
Nestled in Worthington, The Whitney House is a local favorite, offering a cozy, welcoming atmosphere. The menu shines with dishes like the Walleye, seared to perfection and served on a flavorful hash with shrimp and andouille sausage, finished with Cajun butter. This fish also stars in their popular fish sandwich, while the stack burger is another crowd favorite. Their from-scratch kitchen ensures every dish is fresh and thoughtfully prepared, making it a haven for guests with food allergies—many items are gluten-free, including their famous French fries. The cocktail program stands out too, featuring their own aged Manhattans and drinks crafted with in-house ingredients. The restaurant embodies the quaint spirit of Worthington, with many team members hailing from the community and a commitment to supporting local endeavors.
Worthington Tavern
The Worthington Tavern offers a refreshing twist on the classic tavern experience, combining comfort food favorites with a creative flair. Their menu features standout dishes like the Whipped Eggplant with Hearth-Baked Puccia Bread, a must-try take on "bread and butter," and the rich, flavorful pasta alla vodka. Alongside these culinary delights, their extensive cocktail program brings a sophisticated touch to your dining experience. With its laid-back yet refined atmosphere, The Worthington Tavern is the go-to spot for a casual dinner, a special celebration, or simply enjoying a leisurely brunch with friends.
Stone Bar & Kitchen
Stone Bar & Kitchen effortlessly blends modern design with a vibrant, social atmosphere, making it the ideal spot for any gathering. The sleek, contemporary interior and lively bar scene create a hotspot for after-work drinks and weekend outings. The menu features an eclectic array of New American cuisine with a focus on fresh, seasonal ingredients. Standout dishes include the chef’s favorite ribeye steak, perfectly seared and complemented by a house-made black pepper sauce, and the popular crispy bruschetta topped with steak, gorgonzola, and a creative mix of flavors, finished with a classic balsamic glaze. Seafood enthusiasts will enjoy fresh options like shrimp ceviche and PEI mussels. Plus, their brunch menu is not to be missed—try the eggs benedict for a delightful start to your day.
Mehak Indian Kitchen
Mehak Indian Kitchen brings a taste of India to Worthington with its authentic flavors and homey atmosphere. Crafted by veteran chef Ravinder Sharma and his son, the menu features traditional dishes like lamb vindaloo, flavorful biryanis and fresh naan. Don’t miss their house specialties such as saag kofta—crispy vegetable balls in a rich spinach sauce—and chili chicken, which can be customized to your preferred spice level. With vibrant decor and a warm ambiance, Mehak offers a cozy setting for enjoying classics and exploring unique flavors like samosa chaat and scallop masala. It’s a must-visit for anyone craving genuine Indian cuisine.
Next time you’re planning a meal out, be sure to explore these local gems—you’re guaranteed to find something that hits the spot.
There’s nothing like stumbling upon a new favorite restaurant, where the food is so good you’ll dream about it later.