As the air cools and leaves begin to turn, New Braunfels locals know exactly where to go for comfort, flavor, and a little fall indulgence. We’ve rounded up some favorites from around town. These are the cozy lattes, hearty breakfasts, satisfying lunches, and perfectly crafted cocktails that define the season. Whether you're indulging in a butter pecan latte or winding down with smoky mezcal, this is your guide to savoring fall in true New Braunfels style.
Coffee: Betty Lou Coffee
Fall in a cup. Rich, golden, and unapologetically decadent. The Buttery Betty starts with velvety espresso and steamed milk swirled with buttery pecan syrup for that warm, toasted nuttiness that feels like a hug in flannel. It’s topped with a luxurious cloud of salted maple cold foam, and every sip is a balance of sweet and savory, creamy and bold. The finish is a soft kiss of sea salt and caramel warmth that lingers like the perfect autumn afternoon. Cozy, indulgent, and just a little bit fancy, this is your sweater-weather sip with main-character energy.
Breakfast: Buttermilk Cafe
Golden, hearty, and made to slow down with. The French Toast at Buttermilk Cafe features thick slices of wheat berry bread, griddled to perfection with a soft center and crisp edge, then lightly dusted with powdered sugar for just the right touch of sweetness. Topped with fresh strawberries and served with a side of seasonal fruit and a chilled glass of orange juice, it’s a wholesome, feel-good classic that tastes like a weekend morning done right. Simple, beautiful, and delicious—just the way breakfast should be.
Lunch: Cravings
Crafted with a balance of comfort and deliciousness, this turkey and Swiss cheese sandwich offers a modern twist on a timeless favorite. Nestled between two house-baked buns are layers of oven-roasted turkey breast, melted Swiss cheese, and a thinly sliced red onion. This is all topped with a special mixture of goodness, while a handful of fresh spinach introduces color and an earthy freshness that brightens every bite. The finishing touch? A velvety, homemade sauce, tangy & garlic-y with a hint of sweetness, tying all the ingredients together.
Happy Hour and Appetizers: Lost & Found
Lost & Found is the place to grab a drink and some appetizers after a long day. Craving some street tacos? With fresh corn tortillas, flavorful meats, and lucious salsas and sauces, you can't go wrong. Wings are another popular shareable here, and these ones are rotisserie style, making them fall-off-the-bone delectable. The drink menu also has many one-of-a-kind items like the Fuzzy and the Tex-Presso Martini. The Fuzzy is a whiskey sour...with a twist. Freshly made Hefeweizen syrup gives this drink a malty taste while the lemon gives it a bright pop. Love On The Grind? The Tex-Presso Martini features their cold brew alongside Ranch Texas Made vodka, espresso, and cinnamon, making it the perfect way to start your evening or simply relax.
Dinner: The Birdhouse
Named after his wife, Christina's Chicken is the go-to dinner that is sure to round off an amazing day in New Braunfels. Grilled chicken gets its moment with sage goat cheese, dried cranberries, and lemon butter white wine sauce. But the deliciousness doesn't stop there as the chicken is paired with fluffy mashed potatoes and citrus garlic pepper veggies. No meal goes without The Birdhouse's signature cornbread that will perfectly soak up that amazing white wine sauce. Pair your meal with a Rombauer Chardonnay, and this will become your go-to spot when you want to get out of the house and let someone else do the cooking.
Cocktails: Gruene's Last Call
Smoky. Tropical. Tequila. Autumn in Oaxaca is the drink you’ll crave all day. Mi Campo Blanco and 400 Conejos Mezcal lay down a smooth, smoky agave base. Pineapple juice and Queen Caribbean Bitters bring a burst of tropical spice that lights up the mezcal. Maple cinnamon syrup adds a warm, fall-inspired richness, perfectly balanced by a bright splash of lemon juice. From the moment that sweet, sugary rim hits your taste buds all the way to the lingering smooth and spicy finish, this drink delivers comfort, complexity, and a little bit of magic in every sip.