Anyone who’s ever visited Worthington knows that our small businesses are part of the vibrant tapestry of our community. These unique shops and restaurants line our streets with experiences and products that you can’t find anywhere else! But even among the numerous well-known businesses that have become mainstays in our community, there are still a few hidden gems waiting for you to discover them.
Choosing to visit small local businesses brings real creative value to your daily life. Big box stores often mass produce products, but these independent shops, restaurants, artisans, and services offer you a unique product crafted with passion and years of experience. When you buy from them, you’re getting something meaningful—handmade items, unique flavor profiles, and a personal connection to your neighbors. Beyond quality, your patronage directly impacts the real people you live alongside by supporting their passions and dreams. Every purchase helps keep money circulating within your community, strengthening local jobs, and enriching neighborhoods with character and diversity.
Finding these hidden gems also gives you the opportunity to explore your neighborhood and try new things. It feels special because, instead of following the crowd, you’re discovering something new-to-you before everyone else does. Are you ready to find your new favorite place? Check out these four local hidden gems!
Branch Line Leather Studio is a home-grown shop featuring high quality, handmade leather goods. Not only does their shop feature a wide selection of durable jewelry, wallets, journals, and customizable bags, Branch Line also offers many made-to-order purses and backpacks built to your specifications. Most in-store items are made right here in Worthington using genuine top-grain cowhide. With over 30 years of experience, their simple and functional designs are built to last. You can visit their storefront located at 39 W New England Avenue.
History buffs and curio lovers will find plenty to peruse at the Worthington Historical Society Shop at the Old Rectory. The Shop’s specialty is vintage and unique finds, such as silver and brass accessories, artwork, porcelain, pottery, quilts, and other collectables. The shop’s offerings are always changing as new pieces come and old pieces find new homes, but you’ll always find Historical Society merchandise and books about Worthington history here. Be sure and stop in at 50 W New England Avenue to see what’s new!
Stacked Burger is proudly family-owned and is driven by their love of cheeseburgers. Each creative burger on the menu was carefully curated to be an experience in every bite, featuring exciting flavors and made-from-scratch ingredients. Not craving a burger? They won’t judge you—they’ve got brisket, chicken sandwiches, and hot dogs too. The best part is that you don’t have to worry about breaking the bank; you’re getting big flavors at a great price. You can visit them at 1089 Worthington Woods Boulevard.
Shopping for gifts can be tricky, but Shift Studios has something for even the pickiest recipient. This adorable shop specializes in fun, sustainable, and handmade gifts. You’ll certainly find unique jewelry, including a variety of dainty necklaces and earrings, but they also boast a wide array of gifts like handmade candles and incense, natural fragrances, small-batch beauty products, and quirky totes and cards for every taste. Stop in and check out the wares at 693 High Street—you’ll find the entrance through Kittie Cake.