Indulge With Blue Heron Brewery & Event Center

Article by Blue Heron Brewery & Event Center

Photography by Blue Heron Brewery & Event Center

Originally published in Medina County Lifestyle

Oreo Crusted Peanut Butter Pie 

Yield: 6 pies 


+ 1-1/2 lbs., Oreo crumbs

+ 5 oz., Clarified butter

+ 1 cup, peanut butter

+ 8 oz., cream cheese

+ ½ cup, granulated sugar

+ 6 cups whipped cream

+ 2 cups, whipped cream

+ chocolate sauce, as needed

+ caramel sauce, as needed

+ honey roasted peanuts, chopped (as needed)

+ 6 maraschino cherries


1. Combine butter and Oreo crumbs to form the crust.

2. Combine all ingredients except the crust and whipped cream in a mixer on medium speed for five minutes.

3. Add whipped cream and mix on medium speed until incorporated

4. Using a 4-inch springform pan, place 4 oz. of crust in the bottom and press with hand until firm all the way around.

5. Using a rubber spatula, fill the pan with peanut butter mousse and make smooth on top. Refrigerate for two hours.

6. Top with whipped cream, chocolate sauce, caramel sauce, chopped peanuts and, of course, a cherry on top!

Award-Winning in the U.S. Beer Open

Blue Heron Matrimony Ale. Our Flagship beer.

The origin of this beer began when Blue Heron’s brewer and co-owner, Mike Piazza, was a homebrewer crafting beers on a propane burner in his garage. New to homebrewing, he wanted to make a style that would appeal to just about every beer drinker. Thus began the first formulations of Matrimony Ale, an American Cream Ale. Easily drinkable and refreshing, cream ale is referred to as a “lawnmower” beer in many cases. A simple recipe allows the beer to show the pale malt and corn that are the primary ingredients in the style. Fast forward 10 years to now when Blue Heron brought home their first competition medal as professional brewers at the U.S. Open Beer Championship in 2020 with this style. Be sure to check out their coffee of this amazing beer this summer!

  • img_0923-300?v=1
  • peanut%20butter%20pie-300?v=1
  • img_0333-300?v=1

Related Businesses

Crown Center


Crown Center

Kansas City, MO

Visit Crown Center in the heart of Kansas City to find one-of-a-kind shopping, dining, can’t-miss events, and attractions...

Boulevard Brewing Co. Tours and Rec Center


Boulevard Brewing Co. Tours and Rec Center

Kansas City, MO

Just a stone’s throw from the brewery, this is the hub for all tours, shopping and sampling straight from the source. The...

Overland Park Farmers' Market

Specialty Grocery

Overland Park Farmers' Market

Overland Park, KS

The Overland Park Farmers’ Market is a vibrant public gathering place that builds community pride and spirit by bringing...

See More

Related Articles

See More