The High Road Gallery: Worthington’s Creative Heartbeat
Worthington is rich with history, but tucked inside one of its most significant landmarks sits something even more special—a vibrant community art space where local talent comes to life. The High Road Gallery is housed in the Buttles-Pinney-Brown House, built in 1818 and listed on the historic register; a structure that has witnessed two centuries of Worthington’s evolution.
Founded by the late Carol Hershey, who believed deeply in nurturing creativity close to home, the gallery now thrives as a cooperative of artists who live and work right here in our community. Painters, sculptors, and printmakers create in its on-site studios, and their work doesn’t just hang on the walls—it becomes part of the neighborhood’s identity.
Today, artists Nicky Robie and Beth Heisey are at the helm guiding programming, championing artists, and shaping a new vision rooted in connection and engagement. And they are not alone. The resident artists themselves help manage the gallery, each contributing time and talent to keep exhibitions running, programs growing, and history preserved. It is grassroots stewardship in its purest form. “We’re carrying forward Carol’s legacy, but we’re also shaping a new chapter,” Heisey shares. “The artists here aren’t just creating—they’re collaborating, teaching, hosting, and inviting the community in. The High Road Gallery is becoming a living expression of what it means to belong.”
Visitors experience rotating exhibitions, each curated to spotlight the people and perspectives shaping our area’s cultural landscape. From whimsical illustrations to public art, every piece reflects the distinct voice of Worthington’s creative community.
As The High Road Gallery looks ahead to 2026, its focus is clear: art should bring people together. Small concerts, summer gatherings, school collaborations, and themed exhibitions will create opportunities to connect, learn, and participate in a creative life woven into the heart of Worthington.
In a city filled with historic architecture, this building stands apart—not just because of its 1818 bones, but because of what happens inside its storied rooms. If you haven’t stepped inside yet, consider this your invitation. Whether you’re an art lover, a curious resident, or someone who wants to feel more connected to community—this Worthington treasure is ready to welcome you in.
“This gallery doesn't just display work—it’s a place where artists and neighbors meet and build something meaningful together”