From neighborhood breakfast stops to leisurely dinners and locally made sweets, Somerset Hills has plenty of places worth savoring. This month’s Readers’ Choice: Food & Drinks Edition spotlights the establishments that give residents reasons to linger, indulge and come back for another bite.
Each honoree reflects the distinct tastes of the community, from familiar favorites to elevated dining destinations. We’re proud to announce the October 2026 Readers’ Choice winners for Somerset Hills.
Best Bagel Shop
Bagel Garden
A satisfying start to the day is what keeps Bagel Garden in the local rotation, with readers appreciating its fresh bagels and variety of breakfast choices.
@bagelgarden | (908) 526-6444
Best Pizzeria
Lenny’s Pizzeria & Trattoria
Lenny’s combines classic Italian-American favorites with a neighborhood feel, earning support for flavorful pies and a welcoming dining experience.
lennyspizzanj.com | (908) 766-0465
Best Fine Dining
Osteria Morini
Osteria Morini brings Northern Italian-inspired cuisine and an inviting atmosphere to Bernardsville, making it a favorite for lingering dinners and special occasions.
osteriamorini.com | (908) 221-0040
Best Bakery
Sweet Passion Cakery
Sweet Passion Cakery adds a creative touch to celebrations with beautifully finished cakes and desserts made for sharing.
sweetpassioncakery.com | (908) 605-6022
Best Coffee Shop
Barrister Coffee House
A comfortable setting, carefully prepared coffee and a relaxed neighborhood atmosphere make Barrister Coffee House a welcome stop throughout the day.
barristercoffeehouse.com | (908) 340-3136
Worth Savoring Close to Home
Somerset Hills Readers’ Choice winners bring variety to the dining scene, from morning coffee and bagels to pizza and pastries, these neighborhood favorites give residents plenty of delicious ways to gather, celebrate and enjoy time together.
Follow us for upcoming categories and voting at @Bridgewater_Somerset_Hills.