Tucked away in Old Town Temecula, behind rustic wood-planked walls and a soft glow of lamplight, Thompson & Twain Prospecting Co. feels like stepping into another era. Since opening in 2017, this intimate speakeasy has become a favorite among cocktail lovers and in-the-know locals.
Designed by renowned tiki architect Notch Gonzalez (known for Smuggler’s Cove in San Francisco and False Idol in San Diego), the space is moody, low-lit, and intentionally small—just 45 guests—creating a vibe that’s both laid-back and magnetic.
For those who crave more than just a drink—for those who seek a moment—Dealer’s Choice is a cocktail ritual unlike any other. Here, there’s no menu to scan, no signature cocktail to order. Instead, guests are invited into a playful, bespoke exchange with their bartender. You choose your spirit—vodka, tequila, gin, whiskey—and answer a few simple questions. Do you prefer citrusy or smoky? Refreshing or spirit-forward? Allergies? Preferences? Then…you trust.
And that’s where the magic happens.
With practiced hands and a touch of showmanship, the bar team crafts a drink that reflects not just your taste, but your mood, your moment, your evening. Whether it’s shaken, stirred, floral, bitter, or a liquid dessert, the result is a drink that feels uniquely yours—and at $17, it's worth every penny. Feeling adventurous and on a budget? Opt for the $8 twist: a curated version of Dealer’s Choice from a rotating list of preset concoctions.
Doors open daily at 5 PM (3 PM on Sundays), with closing hours stretching to midnight on weekdays and 10 PM on weekends. Seating is first-come, first-served with a two-hour limit—though once you’re inside, you’ll understand why guests need the gentle nudge to move on. “People would stay here all night if we let them,” a bartender laughs. “Trust me—we’ve learned!”
Weekends are lively, with lines forming just before open, especially on Fridays and Saturdays. And yet, despite its growing popularity, Thompson & Twain retains its unshakable sense of cool. It’s not trying to be the loudest place in town—it’s just the one you remember.
Whether you’re a Temecula local or a San Diego visitor seeking a quieter alternative to the city’s party scene, Thompson & Twain offers an experience that’s playful, personalized, and undeniably cool.
So next time you’re wandering Old Town, slow down. Look closer. Behind that unmarked door might just be your new favorite ritual. And if you hear the words, “What’s your spirit of choice?”—you’re in the right place.
Because sometimes, the best stories begin with a drink and a little mystery.
“People would stay here all night if we let them,” a bartender laughs. “Trust me—we’ve learned!”