Every December, beneath the glow of lights and clink of champagne, a quieter truth lingers. For some, it is not the most wonderful time of year, but the loneliest. According to Gallup, nearly one in five Americans feel alone most days, proof that even in a connected world, real connection is rare.
For those facing new chapters after loss, divorce, or years of putting others first, the season can magnify both gratitude and absence. But Scottsdale matchmaker and dating stylist Cat Cantrill believes it can also be a reset for the heart.
Her clients are accomplished professionals who have mastered everything but love. With a background in neuroscience, psychology, and human behavior, she helps them rebuild from within.
“The holidays are when people remember what it feels like to want something deeper, and if you can sit with that longing instead of rushing to fill it, you are already becoming magnetic," says Cat.
Here are her ten insights for a looking-for-love holiday restart.
1. The best time to fall in love is when you stop performing.
“The holidays disarm people. When you’re surrounded by nostalgia, reflection, and family, your emotional walls soften. You start wanting connection, not distraction.”
Cat says that an energy shift- from control to curiosity- changes everything.
“When you’re curious instead of cautious, you listen differently. You stop analyzing and start feeling. That’s when real connection begins.”
2. Charisma isn’t about charm, it’s about calm.
“People think confidence is how loud or visible you are. It’s not. It’s how safe others feel around you. Regulated energy is magnetic. Calm attracts because calm feels safe.”
Cat calls it “nervous system chemistry.”
“If you can stay grounded in yourself… not anxious… people sense it instantly. The right ones move closer.”
3. The real glow-up is emotional availability.
“Emotional availability is the new luxury. It’s someone who knows how to be present without needing control.”
She helps clients distinguish between chemistry and compatibility.
“Butterflies aren’t always a green flag. Sometimes they’re anxiety dressed as excitement. Real attraction feels peaceful, not performative.”
4. Healing is the new flirting.
After divorce or loss, she urges clients not to rush.
“You don’t need to be ‘over it.’ You just need to be self-aware enough not to bleed on someone who didn’t cut you."
“Healing means you can go on a date, stay curious, and still feel like yourself, even if it doesn’t go anywhere. You’re not trying to be chosen; you’re choosing.”
5. Attraction follows authenticity.
“The Valley is stunning, but it can also be performative. People curate their lives like storefronts. But connection happens when you stop performing and start being.”
Her advice: “Your mask might attract attention, but your truth builds connection.”
6. Love now belongs to the emotionally fluent.
“Emotional literacy is the new status symbol. We’ve evolved past games. People want clarity, not mystery.”
In her experience, the most successful daters know how to name what they feel and hold space for others to do the same.
“That’s emotional safety... what everyone’s craving.”
7. Connection hides in your third place.
Cat often helps clients rediscover what she calls their “third place;” a space outside of work and home that nurtures community.
“Love shows up where your nervous system relaxes. A cooking class, a hiking group, a volunteer shift. When you live a life you love, you stop searching and start attracting.”
8. Technology can’t replace presence.
Apps are tools, not solutions.
“You can swipe your way into intimacy and meet someone online, but true connection happens in real time.”
Her rule for clients: “Use apps to expand your world, not shrink your heart.”
9. Slow love is the quiet revolution.
“Fast attraction burns out. Slow love lasts. We’re seeing people reject instant gratification and return to intentional connection.”
She predicts that the future of dating will prize emotional safety over excitement.
“The adrenaline fades, but peace stays. Calm is the new chemistry.”
10. You’re not broken, you’re patterned.
“The biggest shift comes when you realize you’re not broken, you’re just patterned. You’re repeating what feels familiar, even when it hurts.”
Her philosophy: “The moment you start choosing peace over intensity, your love life recalibrates.”
It’s not sentiment, it’s wisdom. After years of watching people rebuild, she knows love begins where self-acceptance does.
“When you finally come home to yourself, love always knows where to find you.”
scottsdalematchmaker.com
“You can swipe your way into intimacy and can meet someone online, but true connection happens in real time, with real energy.”
“Emotional literacy is the new status symbol. We’ve evolved past games. People want clarity, not mystery. In fact, the biggest shift comes when you realize you’re not broken, you’re just patterned. The moment you start choosing peace over intensity, your love life recalibrates.”