Along the Greater Long Branch coast, good food is part of the experience. From a fresh bagel before a beach day to pizza, coffee and a memorable dinner, this month’s Readers’ Choice: Food & Drinks Edition highlights the local spots that give residents and visitors another reason to enjoy the area.
The selections capture the range of flavors and dining experiences that have become part of the community’s local rhythm. We’re proud to announce the October 2026 Readers’ Choice winners for Greater Long Branch.
Best Bagel Shop
FaNagle The Bagel
Fresh bagels and a welcoming atmosphere have made FaNagle The Bagel a neighborhood favorite in Long Branch.
fanagle-the-bagel.com | (732) 571-0066
Best Pizzeria
Scala’s Pizzeria
Scala’s Pizzeria earned its place among local favorites with classic pies, generous portions and a welcoming neighborhood feel.
scalaspizzeria.com | (732) 222-8728
Best Fine Dining
Anjelica’s Restaurant
Anjelica’s offers an elevated coastal dining experience in Sea Bright, ideal for relaxed dinners and special occasions.
anjelicas.com | (732) 842-2800
Best Coffee Shop
Rook Coffee, Long Branch
Rook Coffee has become a go-to for quality coffee and creative drinks, earning recognition for its consistent offerings.
rookcoffee.com | (732) 229-7665
A Taste of Greater Long Branch
Greater Long Branch Readers’ Choice winners capture the local flavors residents return to, from fresh bagels and pizza to coffee and coastal dining. These neighborhood favorites give the community plenty of reasons to gather, indulge and enjoy a meal together.
Follow us for upcoming categories and voting at @GreaterLongBranchCityLifestyle.